Idaho Department of Water Resources

M3 Development Water Right Information

Water Right No. 63-32573, M3 Eagle LLC

August - Remand
September - Remand
October - Remand
November - Remand
December - Remand
Exhibits 1 - 9 and 100
Audio from Oct 18 & 19 Remand Hearing
Administrative and Related Documents - Remand and Contested Case Hearing
Additional Information
Audio from Contested Case Hearing

Documents Related to Remand Hearing and Exhibits

December

Reply Memorandum of the City of Eagle ( KB) -December 7, 2011
Rebuttal Brief and Final Argument ( KB) -December 7, 2011
M3 Eagle's Response to Protestants' and City of Eagle's Post-Hearing Statements ( KB) -December 7, 2011

November

M3 Eagle's Post-Hearing Brief Including Response to Protestants' Motion Challengine Remand Proceedings and City of Eagle's Motion to Strike ( KB) - November 23, 2011
Letter from Cathey Minyard to Renea Ridgeway ( KB) - November 23, 2011
Closing Statement of the City of Eagle ( KB) - November 23, 2011
Closing Statment for North Ada County Groundwater Users Association — Eagle Pines Water Users Association and Norman Edwards ( KB) - November 23, 2011
Final Argument ( KB) - November 23, 2011
Order Granting City of Eagle's Motion for Extension of Time to File Closing Argument Memoranda ( KB) - November 10, 2011
Motion for Extension of Time to File Closing Argument Memoranda ( KB) - November 8, 2011
Letter from Cathy Minyard to Renea Ridgeway ( KB) - November 8, 2011

October

Roster of Attendance for Remand Hearing ( KB) - October 19, 2011
Testimony Log ( KB) - October 18, 2011
Objection and Motion to Strike June 1, 2011 Revised October 4, 2011 RAFN as Amended October 17, 2077 Evaluation for the City of Eagle in Connection with Application for Permit 63-32573 ( KB) - October 18, 2011
Roster of Attendance for Remand Hearing ( KB) - October 18, 2011
Renewed Motion to Dismiss Remand Proceedings ( KB) - October 17, 2011
Order Granting Motion In Limine to Exclude Mary Taylor, Charles Meissner and Mike Moyle as Witnesses ( KB) - October 17, 2011
Notice of Service of City Of Eagle's Proposed Exhibits ( KB) - October 17, 2011
Affidavit of Bruce M. Smith ( KB) - October 17, 2011
Notice of Service of M3 Eagle's Proposed Exhibits ( KB) - October 14, 2011
M3 Eagle's Submission of Deposition Trascripts and Supplemental Brief Relevant to Motion In Limine ( KB) - October 14, 2011
Economic Trends Relevant to Spring Valley, City of Eagle ( KB) - October 14, 2011
Affidavit of Michael P. Lawrence in Support of M3 Eagle's Submission of Deposition Transcripts and Supplemental Brief Relevant to Motion in Limine ( KB) - October 14, 2011
M3 Eagle's Response to Protestant's Motion to Dissmiss Remand Proceedings ( KB) - October 13, 2011
Notice of Cancellation of Deposition of Jason Smith ( KB) - October 12, 2011
Notice of Change of Witness and Notice to Cancel Deposition ( KB) - October 07, 2011
Notice of Depostion Duces Tecum of Mary Taylor ( KB) - October 06, 2011
Notice of Depostion Duces Tecum of Charles Meissner ( KB) - October 06, 2011
Motion to Dismiss Remand Proceedings ( KB) - October 05, 2011
Brief in Support of Motion to Dismiss Remand Proceedings ( KB) - October 05, 2011
Letter to Renea Ridgeway from Cathy Minyard ( KB) - October 05, 2011
City of Eagles Notice of Witnesses ( KB) - October 05, 2011
Response to M3's Reply of September 27, 2001 and Revised Witness List ( KB) - October 04, 2011
Notice of Depostion Duces Tecum of Mike Moyle ( KB) - October 04, 2011
Notice of Depostion Duces Tecum of Jason Smith ( KB) - October 04, 2011
M3 Eagle's Second Objection and Motion In Limine to Exclude Three of Protestants' Four Proposed Witnesses ( KB) - October 04, 2011
Order Limiting Presentation of Evidence at Supplemental Hearing ( KB) - October 03, 2011

September

M3 Eagle's Reply to Mr. Smith's September 15 Objection and September 26 Response ( KB) - September 27, 2011
Response to M3 Objections and Motion to Exclude Protestants' Witnesses ( KB) - September 26, 2011
Deposition Don Reading Ph.D. ( KB) - September 23, 2011
Deposition of Mathew Weaver ( KB) - September 22, 2011
Objection to Prehearing Order ( KB) - September 15, 2011
M3 Eagle's Objection and Motion in Limine to Exclude Protestants' Proposed Witnesses ( KB) - September 13, 2011
City of Eagle's Objection to Pre-Hearing Order as to the Disclosure of Witnesses ( KB) - September 12, 2011
M3 Eagle's Witness Disclosure ( KB) - September 9, 2011
E-Mail from John Homan to Garrick Baxter ( KB) - September 9, 2011
Protestent's List of Potention Witnesses ( KB) - September 8, 2011
Prehearing Order ( KB) - September 8, 2011
M3 Eagle's Response to Protestant's Motion for Clarification and/or Reconsideration ( KB) - September 1, 2011
E-mail from Mathew Weaver to John Homan ( KB) - September 1, 2011

August

Memorandum Decision and Order on Petition for Judicial Review (KB) - August 31, 2011
Public Records Request from Bruce Smith ( KB) - August 25, 2011
Motion for Clarification and.or Reconsideration ( KB) - August 23, 2011
Motion for Subpoenas Duces Tecum to Mat Weaver and Don Reading ( KB) - August 18, 2011
Spring Valley Timeline ( KB)

Exhibits for Remand Hearing

Exhibit 1 - Reasonably Anticipated Future Needs Water Rights Analysis. ( KB) - October 13, 2011
Exhibit 2 - 2011 Eagle Comprehensive Plan ( KB) - February 3, 2011
Exhibit 3 - City of Eagle Amended Master Plan, Volume I ( KB) - November 2005
Exhibit 4 - City of Eagle Amended Master Plan, Master Plan Update #1 ( KB) - March 2008
Exhibit 5 - Ordinance No. 634 ( KB) - November 16, 2009
Exhibit 6 - Resumé of Nichoel R. Baird Spencer, MCRP, AICP ( KB)
Exhibit 7 - Map: Eagle Area of City Impact ( KB)
Exhibit 8 - Economic Trends Relevant to Spring Valley, City of Eagle, John Church, Idaho Economics, ( KB) - October 14, 2011
Exhibit 9 - Spring Valley Timeline ( KB)
Exhibit 100- Rafn Evaluation for the City of Eagle in Connection with Application for Permit 63-32573 ( KB) - Octobler 17, 2011

Audio from October 18^th — 19^th, 2011 Remand Hearing

(2:20:28) Part 1 (132MB)
(3:10:17) Part 2 (178.7MB)
(1:08:32) Part 3 (64MB)

Administrative and Related Documents

Prehearing Order ( KB) - September 8, 2011
M3 Eagle, LLC, Application No. 63-32573, Order Designating Official Transcript ( KB) - January 25, 2010
M3 Eagle, LLC, Application to Appropriate No. 63-32573, Amended Final Order ( KB) - January 25, 2010
M3 Eagle's Petition for Reconsideration of the December 21, 2009 Final Order, Motion to Reopen the Record, and Brief in Support ( KB) - January 4, 2010
M3 Eagle Application to Appropriate No. 63-32573, Final Order ( KB) - December 21, 2009

Supporting Documentation
Document Search Link for Related Files (Documents may take a few seconds to load)
Water Application Report

Additional Information

Audio from Contested Case Hearing

Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5
Day 6
Day 7
Day 8
Day 9
Day 10
Day 11
Day 12
Day 13
Day 14
Day 15
Day 16

Day 1 — Wednesday, April 15, 2009

(01:46:10) Part 1 — William Brownlee, M3
(02:12:39) Part 2 — William Brownlee, M3

Day 2 — Thursday, April 16, 2009

(06:14:15) Part 1

William Brownlee, M3
Dr. John Church, Economist
Steven Holt, Engineer
Scott Wonders, Engineer

Day 3 — Wednesday, April 22, 2009

(02:33:23) Part 1 — Roger Dittus, United Water
(03:07:25) Part 2 — Roger Dittus, United Water; Sean Vincent, IDWR

Day 4 — Thursday, April 23, 2009

(02:10:39) Part 1 — Sean Vincent, IDWR; Ed Squires, Hydro Logic
(02:35:27) Part 2 — Ed Squires, Hydro Logic

Day 5 — Friday, April 24, 2009

(02:22:56) Part 1 — Dr. Spencer Wood, Department of Geosciences, Boise State University
(02:34:55) Part 2 — Ed Squires, Hydro Logic
(00:26:27) Part 2 — Ed Squires, Hydro Logic

Day 6 — Monday, May 4, 2009

(02:39:57) Part 1 — Ed Squires, Hydro Logic
(03:03:34) Part 2 — Ed Squires, Hydro Logic; Richard Glanzman, Glanzman Geochemical, LLC

Day 7 — Tuesday, May 5, 2009

(01:44:08) Part 1 — Richard Glanzman, Glanzman Geochemical, LLC
(01:00:43) Part 2 — Richard Glanzman, Glanzman Geochemical, LLC
(03:13:35) Part 3 — Mark Utting, Hydro Logic

Day 8 — Monday, May 11, 2009

Narrative Testimony from Dennis Owsley - May 11, 2009
Narrative Testimony from Mike McVay - May 11, 2009
Narrative Testimony from Sean Vincent - May 11, 2009

Day 9 — Thursday, May 28, 2009

(02:34:14) Part 1
(01:06:55) Part 2
(02:06:26) Part 3

Day 10 — Friday, May 29, 2009

(02:15:00) Part 1 — Sean Vincent, IDWR; Dale Ralston, IDWR
(02:09:34) Part 2 — Dale Ralston, IDWR

Day 11 — Friday, June 5, 2009

Day 12 — Tuesday, June 23, 2009

(02:17:52) Part 1 — Jason Smith
(00:12:08) Part 2 — Robert Nichols, Public Witness
(00:19:21) Part 3 — Barb Jekell, Public Witness
(00:05:22) Part 4 — Joan Langdon, Public Witness
(00:10:52) Part 5 — Gregory Taylor, Public Witness
(00:08:40) Part 6 — Charles Robert, Public Witness
(00:21:00) Part 7 — Scott Nordstorm, Public Witness
(00:18:16) Part 8 — Stan Bastain, Public Witness
(00:14:02) Part 9 — David Koeppen, Public Witness
(00:19:58) Part 10 — Patricia Minkiewicz, Public Witness
(01:00:56) Part 11 — Jason Smith

Day 13 — Thursday, July 9, 2009

(00:34:53) Part 1 — Jason Smith
(00:21:46) Part 2 — Jason Smith
(00:37:44) Part 3 — Jason Smith
(00:09:58) Part 4 — Tom Sorgy
(00:10:46) Part 5 — Motion to Dismiss
(00:21:46) Part 6 — Dr. Wood
(00:41:05) Part 7 — Rob Whitney
(00:20:58) Part 8 — Rob Whitney
(00:20:57) Part 9 — Rob Whitney
(00:07:15) Part 10 — Clarification of Expert Witnesses
(00:58:54) Part 11 — Dr. Wood
(00:01:49) Part 12 — Dr. Wood
(00:03:21) Part 13 — Dr. Wood
(00:05:55) Part 14 — Dr. Wood
(00:51:14) Part 15 — Ed Squires
(00:02:34) Part 16 — Closing

Day 14 — Tuesday, July 21, 2009

(02:22:02) Part 1 — Ed Squires, HydroLogic, Inc.
(03:16:30) Part 2 — Ed Squires, HydroLogic, Inc.

Day 15 — Wednesday, July 22, 2009

(00:21:09) Part 1 — Ed Squires, HydroLogic, Inc.
(00:21:44) Part 2 — Jack Van Wyk, Public Witness
(01:32:29) Part 3 — Dr. James Osiensky, University of Idaho, Moscow - Professor of Hydrogeology
(00:51:03) Part 4 — Dr. James Osiensky, University of Idaho, Moscow - Professor of Hydrogeology
(01:08:04) Part 5 — Sean Vincent, IDWR
(00:19:13) Part 6 — Carter Froelich, Development Planning & Financial Group, Inc.

Day 16 — Thursday, July 30, 2009

(02:04:47) Part 1 — Carter Froelich (continuation)
(00:55:05) Part 2 — Bill Brownlee, M3
(00:42:38) Part 3 — Bill Brownlee, M3 (continuation)
(00:13:53) Part 4 — Dennis Owsley, IDWR
(01:53:16) Part 5 — Sean Vincent, IDWR
(00:00:51) Part 6 — Close of Hearing